top of page
  • Writer's pictureAhsan Malyk

Is It Better To Have Deductible Or No Deductible Insurance?

A no-deductible health insurance plan is a health insurance plan with a zero deductible, with immediate co-insurance and out-of-pocket benefits. These plans are suitable if you anticipate high medical expenses during your policy year.

Non-deductible health insurance typically has higher monthly premiums, but it can help you avoid some costs and save money on your overall annual costs.

Is liability insurance not right for me?

Health insurance without deductibles is a good option if you anticipate high medical costs. Paying a higher monthly fee for a nondeductible plan can save you money in the long run if you anticipate needing significant medical benefits in the coming year, such as a health checkup and expensive interventions, or repeated treatments.

There are cost tradeoffs, so a nondeductible plan isn't for everyone. In general, the lower the deductible, the higher the monthly fee for the plan. For this reason, plans without deductions can be the most expensive policies available.

What is health insurance without deductibles?

A non-deductible policy means you get the full cost-sharing benefits of your plan right away. You don't have to pay a specific amount out-of-pocket before your insurance company can start paying for covered medical services.

For example, suppose you receive a $2,500 insured medical procedure. In that case, a nondeductible plan means that the insurance company will pay for the total amount of the procedure from day one of the policy. If he had the same medical procedure and a $1,000 deductible on his insurance plan, he would have paid his first $1,000 before the insurance company shared the cost.

How do plans without deductibles work?

The biggest difference between no-deductible health insurance and other types of health insurance is when the insurer starts paying for the insured medical services.

Plans without deductibles start paying copayments immediately, while other plans start paying copayments after paying copayments up to the deductible. This timing can affect the total amount of medical expenses you pay each year.

The structure of health insurance plans is similar to that of plans with deductibles, but there are still some costs and other criteria. Here are the basics of how nondeductible plans work:

  • High monthly fee: Plans without deductibles have higher monthly premiums, but the benefits of full cost sharing are in effect from day one.

  • Payment of medical expenses: It also pays for copayments or coinsurance that you pay for services such as doctor visits. There is also an upper limit for self-pay. This is the annual spending cap for network co-payments and co-insurance.

  • Policy exclusions: Even with a non-deductible plan, you may still be fully responsible for out-of-network care and uninsured medical services. Carefully review your exclusion plans, especially the provider network type for this policy.

What should I consider when choosing health insurance without a deductible?

Large joint payments offset some non-deductible plans. If the monthly fee for a non-deductible plan seems too high, look for potential downsides such as a very high cost per doctor visit or a limited number of providers using in-network tariffs.

What about metal tiers with no deductible plans?

When you purchase a policy through the health insurance marketplace, you will find deductible plans in all metal levels, including Bronze, Silver, Gold, and Platinum.

As a rule of thumb, Gold and Platinum plans have lower deductibles than Silver or Bronze plans. However, we have recently seen new plans added in some locations, including Bronze and Silver policies with no overages. These plans are based on other aspects of coverage, such as: they will be canceled. High deductibles, limited networks, high coinsurance, and more.

For example, comparing non-deductible health insurance policies in Texas, the out-of-pocket cost for an X-ray on the network is $70 for the Gold plan, $80 for the Silver plan, and $140 for the Bronze plan.

What is the average cost of health insurance without deductibles?

The average monthly cost for health insurance plans with no and low deductibles ranges from $592 to $678. Annual premiums for these insurance plans equate to $7,104 to $8,136. However, the exact cost will depend on your circumstances and your chosen health insurance plan.

Comparison of cost scenarios for insurance without deductibles

When comparing health insurance plans, be aware that the amount you can deduct from your insurance can affect the total medical expenses you pay each year. This is especially important when comparing non-deductible health insurance to other types of health insurance. Let's look at two example scenarios to see how insurance without deductions affects medical costs.

In situations where you are likely to need critical medical care or costly procedures, paying a higher monthly premium can reduce your overall costs.

In the above scenario, a person on a plan with no deductible would pay $650 monthly for health insurance, totaling $7,800 a year. You do not have to pay the deductible amount before benefits begin. However, you will continue paying your usual copayment or mutual aid for hospital visits and treatment.

This brings her annual medical bills under $8,000 on a non-deductible plan. If someone in the same situation had a plan with a higher deductible, their total annual medical expenses would exceed $11,000. This includes a monthly bill of $386 plus her $6,500 extra for covered services before deductibles are met.

What should I consider for an insurance policy without a deductible?

Health insurance plans without deductibles are generally best for people who expect high annual medical costs. However, it's usually not the cheapest health insurance plan on the market. Below are some factors that can help you decide if a nondeductible plan is the best option.

  • Estimated Medical Expenses: Ask yourself how much medical care you will need next year. Older people, those at higher risk, or those with ongoing medical conditions can benefit from nondeductible plans because insurers begin paying insured medical benefits immediately. Note that most plans offer full retirement coverage, regardless of whether the plan has a deductible.

  • Financial impact: If you choose a plan without a deductible, you'll buy insurance with a higher monthly cost, but it will protect you from large medical bills and expenses. In contrast, plans with higher deductibles can help lower your monthly bill, but significant medical issues can result in higher out-of-pocket costs.

  • Risk and predictability: Health care costs are generally more predictable with nondeductible plans. You can reduce your anxiety about unexpected medical expenses by paying a fixed amount for monthly insurance premiums and co-payments.

Choosing a no-deductible plan would save him $3,332 in this situation.

2 views0 comments


Post: Blog2_Post
bottom of page